Space menu
Double-Blind Peer Review
# Double-blind peer review
> Related guidance: [Curation Status Labels](wiki:#).
## Purpose of this guidance
DataverseNO supports the use of research datasets during double-blind peer review.
This page explains how curators can prepare an anonymized version of a dataset for sharing with editors and reviewers while preserving author anonymity.
The process ensures that:
- reviewers can inspect the underlying data;
- authors remain anonymous during review;
- the original dataset can later be published in DataverseNO using its assigned DOI.
## When does this apply?
Use this workflow when:
- a manuscript is being evaluated through **double-blind peer review**;
- reviewers need access to the underlying data before publication;
- sharing the original dataset would reveal author identity.
The need for an anonymized review dataset is usually indicated by the depositor in the **Related Publication** metadata field when submitting the dataset. In some cases, the depositor may instead contact their local support service or curator directly and request support for double-blind peer review.
In these situations, the standard DataverseNO preview workflow is not sufficient because information about the depositor may be visible in the dataset version history and other metadata. The curator must therefore prepare an anonymized review copy of the dataset before reviewer access is provided.
## Workflow overview
The workflow below summarizes the main stages involved in supporting double-blind peer review in DataverseNO:
1. Curate the original dataset as usual.
2. Prepare the original dataset for publication.
3. Create an anonymized copy of the dataset.
4. Share the anonymized dataset via a Preview URL.
5. Support the review process.
6. Publish the original dataset after article acceptance.
7. Delete the anonymized review dataset.
## Detailed workflow
### 1\. Curate the original dataset
Curate the originally submitted dataset according to the normal DataverseNO curation workflow.
The goal is to ensure that the dataset aligns with the Deposit Guidelines before it is shared with reviewers.
The original dataset should **not** be published at this stage.
### 2\. Accessing the review collection
Once the original dataset is ready for sharing, the curator must create an anonymized copy of the dataset in the DataverseNO collection dedicated to double-blind peer review.
To access the review collection:
1. Contact the Dataverse Repository Management team at [support@dataverse.no](mailto:support@dataverse.no) and request access to the DataverseNO Review Curator account.
2. Log out of DataverseNO as your normal curator account, or open an incognito/private browser window.
3. Log in using the credentials provided for the Review Curator account.
4. Navigate to the [DataverseNO review collection](https://dataverse.no/dataverse/review).
5. Create a new anonymized dataset draft in this collection.
### Notes
Collection names, URLs, login procedures, and account details may change over time. If the documented procedure no longer works, contact the Repository Management team.
### 3\. Create an anonymized review copy
Create a separate anonymized copy of the curated dataset in the review collection. The anonymized dataset is a temporary review copy. It is not the dataset that will later be published
### 4\. Anonymize the dataset
Before sharing the review dataset, follow the **anonymization checklist** below to verify that:
#### Metadata
☐ Author names have been removed or replaced with **Anon.**
☐ Contact information has been anonymized.
☐ Producer information has been anonymized.
☐ Other metadata fields do not reveal author identity.
#### Documentation
☐ Author-identifying information has been anonymized or removed from the README file.
☐ Author-identifying information has been anonymized or removed from other documentation.
☐ References to institutions, projects, websites, repositories, acknowledgements, or funding information do not compromise anonymity.
#### Files
☐ Author information has been anonymized or removed from embedded file metadata.
☐ File properties and document metadata have been reviewed.
☐ Identifying information has been anonymized or removed from all relevant files.
#### Dataset review
☐ A reviewer would not be able to identify the author from the dataset contents.
### 5\. Generate a Preview URL
Create a Preview URL for the anonymized dataset and share it with the depositor.
The anonymized dataset serves as a temporary review copy that the depositor can share with editors and reviewers as required by the publisher or journal.
Before sharing the Preview URL, verify once more that the anonymized dataset does not contain information that could reveal the identity of the author(s).
#### Mark the original dataset as being in double-blind review
Once the anonymized review copy has been created, the curator should assign the curation label **In Double Blind Review** to the **original dataset**.
The purpose of this label is to clearly indicate that the dataset is currently being used in a double-blind peer review process and that a separate anonymized review copy exists.
If the collection maintains an overview, spreadsheet, tracker, or similar mechanism for monitoring datasets in curation, the curator should also update that overview accordingly. This helps ensure that datasets undergoing double-blind review can be easily identified and followed up throughout the review process.
#### Keep the original dataset unchanged during review
Once the anonymized review copy has been created and is ready to be shared with editors and reviewers, the original dataset should normally remain under curator control and should **not** be returned to the depositor for editing.
The purpose of this practice is to ensure that the original dataset and the anonymized review copy remain identical apart from the anonymization applied to the review copy.
Allowing changes to the original dataset while the anonymized review copy is being used during peer review may make it difficult to:
- Keep track of differences between the two datasets.
- Ensure that reviewers and future users are working with the same version of the data.
- Determine which changes were introduced during the review process.
- Maintain a clear and transparent publication workflow.
If the depositor needs to make changes while the manuscript is under review, the curator should first assess the scope of the requested changes. Where changes are necessary, the original dataset may be returned to the depositor, but the curator should ensure that corresponding changes are subsequently reflected in the anonymized review copy before further review takes place.
#### Suggested email to the depositor
The following wording may be adapted and used when communicating with the depositor:
> Dear NN,
>
> I have now created an anonymized version of your dataset for use during double-blind peer review.
>
> The anonymized dataset can be accessed through the following Preview URL:
>
> [https://dataverse.no/previewurl.xhtml?token=12345ab0-a123-1234-1a12-123ab1a2bcd2](https://dataverse.no/previewurl.xhtml?token=12345ab0-a123-1234-1a12-123ab1a2bcd2)
>
> You may share this URL with the journal editor(s) and, where appropriate, with reviewers.
>
> Before doing so, please review the anonymized dataset carefully and verify that it does not contain information that could reveal your identity.
>
> The anonymized dataset is a temporary review copy and will be deleted once your manuscript has been accepted for publication. The dataset that will ultimately be published is the original dataset that you submitted and that we have curated.
>
> For this reason, your manuscript should refer to the **original dataset**, but in an anonymized form. You may adapt the wording as required by the journal style guide.
>
> **Example:**
>
> It is important that you refer to the **original dataset DOI** rather than the anonymized dataset because the original and anonymized datasets have different DOIs. The original dataset DOI will remain valid when the dataset is eventually published.
>
> Once your manuscript has been accepted for publication, please update the dataset references in the manuscript as follows:
>
> - Replace Anon. with the actual author name(s).
> - If necessary, update the publication year to reflect the year in which the dataset was published.
> - Use the activated DOI link.
> - Replace Draft version with Version 1 (V1).
> - Remove the sentence referring to the anonymized review dataset.
>
> Any anonymized in-text citations should also be updated accordingly.
>
> When you are ready to publish the dataset, please contact us.
>
> If editors or reviewers request changes to the dataset during the review process, please contact us before making any modifications. The original dataset should remain unchanged while the anonymized review copy is being used for peer review. If updates are required, we will return the original dataset to you and coordinate any necessary updates to both the original and anonymized versions.
>
> Finally, once the related publication has been published, please update the Related Publication field in the dataset metadata to include a reference to the published paper. This will normally result in a minor version change of the dataset metadata, which does not affect the recommended dataset citation.
>
> Thank you for choosing DataverseNO to archive and share your research data.
>
> Best regards,
>
> NN
### Notes
The anonymized review dataset and the original dataset are separate records with separate DOIs. The manuscript should always refer to the DOI of the original dataset, as this is the dataset that will eventually be published and cited.
## After article acceptance
### 6\. Publish the original dataset
After the manuscript has been accepted:
- If requested by the depositor or required as a result of the peer-review process, make sure any necessary changes to the original dataset are made and reviewed before publication.
- Publish the original curated dataset.
- Verify that references in the publication point to the original dataset.
### 7\. Remove the anonymized review dataset
Once it is no longer needed, the anonymized review dataset should be deleted.
## Need help?
If you are unsure how to anonymize a dataset, provide reviewer access, or handle dataset references during peer review, contact:
- Your local curation team; and, if needed,
- The Repository Management team at [support@dataverse.no](mailto:support@dataverse.no).
Powered by HumHub